Loading…
Loading…
North Carolina 2026 General Midterm Election
The judge applies binding appellate decisions and considers other relevant past decisions.
From “Apply past decisions broadly to promote consistency” to “Distinguish past decisions when the facts or legal context differ”.
Updated November 4, 2026 from published sources.
Sarah Stevens (Republican)
Leans toward: Apply past decisions broadly to promote consistency
Stevens generally opposes overturning precedent unless it clearly violates the constitution.
“I don't think you should upset precedent unless it's clearly a violation of the constitution”
Stevens criticizes her opponent for disturbing longstanding common law.
“She has also rewritten the law and disturbed 90 years of common law.”
Anita Earls (Democratic)
Leans toward: Apply past decisions broadly to promote consistency
Earls opposed rehearing a finished redistricting case and reversing its ruling.
“The court's action in rehearing a case — and reversing the ruling in that case — is really unprecedented”
Earls says courts should not change their determination of the law within the same case as litigation continues.
“once you've decided what the law is in a particular case, you shouldn't change it as the litigation goes forward.”
Earls says courts should respect precedent so people bringing similar cases are treated equally.
“once you've decided what the law is, you don't change that.”
Michael C. Byrne (Republican)
Leans toward: Apply past decisions broadly to promote consistency
Byrne says he follows case law precedent when interpreting an ambiguous statute.
“There is case law precedent for this process and I follow it.”
Byrne says he follows case-law precedent for resolving ambiguity in statutes.
“There is case law precedent for this process and I follow it.”
John S. Arrowood (Democratic)
Leans toward: Apply past decisions broadly to promote consistency
Arrowood says the Court of Appeals should apply existing precedent when reviewing trial court decisions.
“our job is to see and to apply the law equally and without favor to see if, in fact, the trial court erred and to apply the precedence that we have.”
George Cooper Bell (Republican)
Mixed or in between
Bell says judges should follow precedent, but not to the exclusion of the Constitution.
“The judge should follow precedent, but not to the exclusion of our Constitution. The Constitution matters and it should be upheld.”
Tobias (Toby) Hampson (Democratic)
Leans toward: Apply past decisions broadly to promote consistency
Hampson values consistent precedent because it helps people predict the law and make decisions before going to court.
“they can do that when they're able to predict based on consistent precedent we're setting out”
Hampson says he followed a precedent he thought was wrong but wrote separately to urge the state Supreme Court to revisit it.
Craig Collins (Republican)
Leans toward: Distinguish past decisions when the facts or legal context differ
Collins says courts must correct interpretations that are clearly erroneous and have no basis in law.
“Courts have an obligation to correct error when the interpretation of the law was clearly erroneous and had no basis in the law.”
Christine Marie Walczyk (Democratic)
Leans toward: Apply past decisions broadly to promote consistency
Walczyk values precedent because it provides consistency and stability in the law.
“I believe in precedent. Because society needs consistency, stability.”
Chad Hogston (Republican)
We have not found a statement or vote from this candidate on this issue yet.
Katherine Corpening (Democratic)
Leans toward: Apply past decisions broadly to promote consistency
Corpening emphasizes using past court decisions to promote consistency and says judges should stay current with case law.
“so that that there is that consistency in how the law is applied, and really grounding your arguments in decisions that have already been made, and really rooting it in that. I think that it's important for judges to really look for case law, stay up to date on changes in the law, because there are changes in best practices.”
Earls said it was unprecedented for the court to rehear an already decided case after a mere change in its membership.
“the mere change in the personnel would then lead the court to rehear a case, the same case that it had already decided”
Earls generally supports following precedent, while allowing exceptions in some circumstances.
“They believe the court should generally uphold precedent, except in some circumstances where it shouldn’t.”
“I recognized I was bound by that prior precedent, but wrote a separate concurring opinion to the majority opinion explaining why I thought it was wrong and why I thought the state Supreme Court should take up the issue”
Walczyk also says some past decisions needed to be reversed because they were wrong, citing cases involving segregation and interracial marriage.
“Over time, society evolved and grew, and those things needed to be reversed because they were wrong.”
Walczyk says she respects precedent and believes in judicial restraint.
“I believe in precedent. I respect precedent. I believe in judicial restraint.”
Walczyk says courts should be cautious about departing from prior decisions because consistency and stability matter.
“Courts should exercise caution in departing from prior decisions of the same or a higher court, as consistency and stability are essential to a safe and peaceful society.”
Walczyk says she respects precedent and believes consistency and stability are essential.
“I respect precedent and believe in judicial restraint, as consistency and stability are essential to a safe and peaceful society.”