Loading…
Loading…
North Carolina 2026 General Midterm Election
The judge considers challenges to government actions while observing legal limits on judicial authority.
From “Give greater deference to decisions of elected branches” to “Apply more independent scrutiny to decisions of elected branches”.
Updated November 4, 2026 from published sources.
Sarah Stevens (Republican)
Leans toward: Give greater deference to decisions of elected branches
Stevens says courts should follow laws enacted by the legislature unless they find a constitutional issue, rather than change the law.
“it's not a part of the court to change the law, but to simply follow it as written by the General Assembly unless you find a constitutional issue.”
Stevens says laws should be applied as written and judges should not create laws from the bench.
“judges shouldn't create laws from the bench.”
Stevens says judges should not create laws from the bench.
“judges shouldn't create laws from the bench”
Stevens says the legislature, not the court, should address changes in the medical profession when the statute has not changed.
“Stevens said it’s simply not the job of the court to consider evidence or arguments along those lines. It’s the legislature’s job to address those sorts of concerns, she said, not the court’s.”
Anita Earls (Democratic)
Leans toward: Apply more independent scrutiny to decisions of elected branches
Earls says courts should check the executive and legislative branches to ensure they follow the state constitution.
“serve as a check and balance on the other two branches of government. In particular, making sure that both the executive and the legislative branches follow the state constitution.”
Earls says the court should hold the executive and legislature accountable to the state constitution.
“The court's function is to make sure that both the executive and the legislature are held accountable to the guarantees in the state constitution”
Earls says judicial restraint means courts interpret laws rather than write them.
“judicial restraint says we only interpret the laws, we don't write the laws.”
Michael C. Byrne (Republican)
Leans toward: Apply more independent scrutiny to decisions of elected branches
Byrne says he ruled that DEQ's conditions on agricultural permits were illegal and required rulemaking, and that the state Supreme Court affirmed his decision.
“And it involved DEQ attaching conditions to general agricultural permits, primarily doing with hog farms. And I decided that that was an illegal exercise that required, you know, rule making”
Byrne cites as a judicial hero a justice who struck down a state law denying jury trials.
“My judicial hero: Samuel Ashe of the NC Supreme Court, who in Bayard v. Singleton (1787) nullified a NC law denying jury trials (a right enshrined in our State Constitution) years before Marbury v. Madison (1803).”
Byrne praises a judge who struck down a law that conflicted with constitutional jury-trial rights, even though the people affected were unpopular.
“And Judge Ash looked at that law and said, "This law denies the right to jury trial, and it simply cannot stand as it conflicts with the Constitution." Now, what's cool about that is two things. One, that had never been done before. That was years before the Supreme Court of the United States did it for the first time in 1803 in Marbury v. Madison. The second thing is the courage that took. Can you think of a more unpopular group of people in 1787 than people who were loyal to King George? But he didn't care. He said, "Those constitutional rights apply to everyone, and they will be enforced," and I think that's a very courageous act, so he is my judicial hero.”
George Cooper Bell (Republican)
Leans toward: Give greater deference to decisions of elected branches
Bell describes judicial restraint as using caution and deference to avoid creating new law and respect separation of powers.
“Judicial restraint is when a judge uses caution and deference, in deciding legal issues in an attempt to not create new law, realizing the separation of power between the judiciary and legislative branches.”
Tobias (Toby) Hampson (Democratic)
Leans toward: Apply more independent scrutiny to decisions of elected branches
Hampson says courts should be willing to check the other branches of government.
“I think we do need courts that are willing to stand up to the other two political branches of government and serve as a check and balance on those.”
Craig Collins (Republican)
Leans toward: Give greater deference to decisions of elected branches
Collins says courts should review the constitutionality of laws rather than make policy.
“The Court should not involve itself in policy. The Court’s role is to ensure the Constitutionality of such laws, not make those laws.”
Collins favors judicial restraint and warns against courts overstepping their role or writing laws from the bench.
“Judicial restraint is necessary to protect our form of government. The Courts have always been the final arbitrator of what is Constitutional, but that only works when the Courts restrain themselves from overstepping their proper role. Activist judges who desire to write laws from the bench risk a constitutional crisis.”
Collins says judges should follow the Constitution and not legislate from the bench.
“North Carolina needs experienced judges who will follow the Constitution and not legislate from the bench.”
Stevens says the court’s previous Democratic majority went too far in overturning actions by the legislature.
“But Stevens says it’s the court’s previous Democratic majority — including Earls — who went too far in overturning actions by the legislature.”
Earls says courts have the power to enforce rights, including education and voting rights, rather than treating their protection as beyond judicial authority.
“Whenever the court doesn't want to enforce or protect those rights, they suggest that it's beyond their power. But that's I think that's just a complete misinterpretation of the law.”
Earls says the court should meaningfully check constitutional rights violations, including those originating from the legislature.
“The current Court appears unable or unwilling to meaningfully check constitutional rights violations—particularly those originating from the legislature.”
Earls says an independent court is necessary to maintain the balance of powers.
“I believe an independent Court is critically necessary to the balance of powers and absolutely required to maintain a democracy.”
John S. Arrowood (Democratic)
Leans toward: Apply more independent scrutiny to decisions of elected branches
Arrowood says he is committed to an independent judiciary that upholds the rule of law.
“I am committed to an independent judiciary that upholds the rule of law.”
Arrowood says courts should act as a check on the political branches of government.
“acting as a check and balance on the political branches of government”
Arrowood agrees with a statement concerning prohibiting districts that diminish some groups’ voting strength, but says he cannot promise how he would rule on districting cases.
“Arrowood (D) : Agree. Please note this answer should not be taken as a promise as to how I will rule on any case that might come before me with respect to how districts are drawn.”
Hampson says the judicial branch and the other branches of government should keep one another in check.
“those guardrails, you know, keep us as a judicial branch in check, just like we're supposed to keep the other branches of government in check.”
Hampson says courts should independently check the legislature to protect North Carolinians’ rights.
“Courts should act as an independent check and balance on the legislature to protect the rights of all North Carolinians, including the right to vote and participate in free and fair elections.”
Hampson says courts should be willing to serve as a check on the other branches of government.
“I think we do need courts that are willing to stand up to the other two political branches of government and serve as a check and balance on those.”
Hampson favors judicial restraint: deciding the case before the court without making sweeping decisions on policy issues.
“It's not trying to make wide-reaching decisions that can impact policy issues. It's deciding the case in front of you based on the facts, based on the law, based on the procedure”
Collins says judges should not use court orders to amend the law.
“the court needs judges who won’t use the courts to “amend the law … through court order.””
Christine Marie Walczyk (Democratic)
Leans toward: Apply more independent scrutiny to decisions of elected branches
Walczyk wants an independent court that keeps the other branches of government within constitutional bounds.
“I want to build a more independent court that's free from the influence of the General Assembly. I want to build a court that's stronger and more balanced and actually has the ability to serve its purpose of keeping those other two branches within constitutional bounds.”
Walczyk says courts should ensure the elected branches comply with the Constitution.
“But if the other two political branches are not meeting their constitutional obligations or if they are running afoul of the Constitution, then it is our job to make sure that there's constitutional compliance.”
Walczyk supports an independent court that checks the other branches for compliance with constitutional limits.
“I believe we need a balanced, stronger court that can prevent abuses of power, and ensure that the other two political branches remain within constitutional bounds.”
Walczyk supports an independent judiciary that checks the other branches of government.
“The judiciary is meant to be a coequal branch of government that serves as a check on the other two political branches”
Walczyk says courts must serve as a check on the other branches of government.
“Courts must serve as a check on the other two political branches.”