Loading…
Loading…
North Carolina 2026 General Midterm Election
How a judge reads the law.
From “the text and its original meaning” to “its purpose and present-day circumstances”.
Updated November 4, 2026 from published sources.
Sarah Stevens (Republican)
Leans toward: the text and its original meaning
On reading state statutes: Stevens says courts should apply the law as written.
“listen carefully to both sides, apply the law as it's written, and then ensure that all the constitutional protections have been there.”
On reading the constitution: Stevens says she would follow the constitution as written.
“I'm the constitutional conservative who will follow the constitution as written, and the laws as written”
On reading state statutes: Stevens says she would follow laws as written rather than as she wants them to be.
“the laws as written,” she said. “Not as I want them to be.”
On reading the constitution: Stevens supports strictly following the Constitution.
“I believe in following the law as written and a strict following of the constitution.”
On reading state statutes: Stevens says the law should be applied as written.
“Sarah Stevens believes the law should be applied as written and judges shouldn't create laws from the bench.”
On reading state statutes: Stevens says laws should be applied as written.
“applied as written and judges shouldn't create laws from the bench.”
On reading state statutes: Stevens says judges should follow statutes as written.
“A judge follows the law and constitutions as written and not as she wants it to be.”
On reading state statutes: Stevens says judges should follow the law as written rather than as they wish it to be.
“They follow the law as written not as they want it to be.”
On reading state statutes: Stevens says judges should follow the law as written.
“I believe in following the law as written”
On reading the constitution: Stevens says judges should follow constitutions as written.
“A judge follows the law and constitutions as written and not as she wants it to be.”
On reading the constitution: Stevens identifies constitutional originalism as a priority.
“Her top issues are prioritizing child welfare, constitutional originalism and judicial restraint.”
Anita Earls (Democratic)
Mixed or in between
On reading the constitution: Earls says constitutional rights should be understood in light of modern conditions and conceptions of human rights, rather than being frozen in the past.
“Our understanding of the rights embodied in the state and federal constitutions should not be frozen in amber based on the narrow circumstances or prejudices of centuries past. Fundamental democratic principles require that our constitutional rights be based on modern conditions and conceptions of human rights.”
On reading the constitution: Earls says constitutional rights should be understood in light of modern conditions and conceptions of human rights.
“Fundamental democratic principles require that our Constitutional rights be based on modern conditions and conceptions of human rights.”
On reading state statutes: Earls says she interprets statutes by examining their text and using relevant interpretive tools to carry out the law's intent.
“I interpret constitutional provisions and statutes by looking at the actual text of the provisions and applying all relevant interpretative tools to effectuate the intent of the law.”
Michael C. Byrne (Republican)
Mixed or in between
On reading state statutes: When a statute’s text is ambiguous, Byrne says the ultimate obligation is to follow the General Assembly’s intent.
“The ultimate obligation is to follow the General Assembly's intent in enacting the statute at issue.”
On reading state statutes: When a statute is ambiguous, Byrne says the ultimate obligation is to follow the General Assembly's intent in enacting it.
“The ultimate obligation is to follow the General Assembly's intent in enacting the statute at issue”
On reading state statutes: Byrne says his role is to implement the law enacted by the General Assembly.
“I just, you know, implement the law that the General Assembly put in place.”
George Cooper Bell (Republican)
Leans toward: the text and its original meaning
On reading state statutes: Bell says clear text controls and that he consults legislative minutes to determine intent when a law is ambiguous.
“For cases where the text is clear, the plain meaning language controls. If there is an ambiguity of a statute or law, I always pull the legislative minutes to determine the legislative intent behind the law.”
On reading state statutes: Bell says judges may consider present-day public opinion or consequences when interpreting law, but those considerations should not be decisive.
“When applying or interpreting the text of a statute or constitutional provision, is it ever proper for a judge to consider present day public opinion or consequences? Yes, but not dispositive.”
Craig Collins (Republican)
Leans toward: the text and its original meaning
On reading state statutes: Collins says the Constitution means what it says and should not be rewritten to fit a political agenda.
“I believe the Constitution means what it says, and I will never re-write it to fit some political agenda.”
On reading state statutes: Collins says judges should follow the Constitution as written rather than amend it to fit a political agenda.
“The Constitution means what it says, and we need judges who will always follow it and never amend it to fit a political agenda.”
On reading state statutes: Collins says judges should follow the Constitution as written rather than use court orders to amend it.
Jonathan C. Strange (Republican)
Leans toward: the text and its original meaning
On reading state statutes: Jonathan C. Strange states that judges should follow laws as they are written rather than determining what the law should say.
“I believe judges should follow the Constitution and the laws as they are written.”
On reading the constitution: Jonathan C. Strange states that judges should follow the Constitution as it is written.
“I believe judges should follow the Constitution and the laws as they are written.”
Cheri Siler-Mack (Democratic)
We have not found a statement or vote from this candidate on this issue yet.
Kurt B. Fryar (Republican)
Leans toward: the text and its original meaning
On reading state statutes: Fryar believes laws should be applied as written.
“Kurt believes laws should be applied as they are written.”
On reading state statutes: Fryar believes laws should be applied as written.
“Kurt believes laws should be applied as they are written.”
James H. Faison III (Democratic)
We have not found a statement or vote from this candidate on this issue yet.
On reading the constitution: Earls also says courts should consider the original purpose and intent of a constitutional provision when applying it to current circumstances.
“to understand the purpose and intent of the original provision and how that might apply in current circumstances.”
On reading the constitution: Earls says constitutional interpretation should begin with the actual language.
“the first thing we look to in interpreting a statute or a constitutional revision is the actual language.”
On reading state statutes: Earls says she interprets statutes by examining their text and using relevant interpretive tools to effectuate the law’s intent.
“I interpret constitutional provisions and statutes by looking at the actual text of the provisions and applying all relevant interpretative tools to effectuate the intent of the law.”
On reading state statutes: Earls says courts should begin interpreting statutes with their actual language and follow established rules of interpretation.
“the first thing we look to in interpreting a statute or a constitutional revision is the actual language.”
On reading state statutes: Byrne says cases should be decided strictly based on the law, without fear or favor.
“I believe passionately in due process, fairness, giving all sides a chance to be heard, and deciding cases strictly based on the law, without fear or favor.”
On reading state statutes: Byrne favors interpreting the law according to its original meaning without considering present-day opinion or consequences.
“Byrne identifies Antonin Scalia as his model, says judges should follow original meaning without considering present-day opinion or consequences”
On reading state statutes: Byrne invokes original intent and says present-day public opinion or consequences should not be considered when applying or interpreting law.
“In published questionnaire answers, Byrne identifies Antonin Scalia as the U.S. Supreme Court justice who best reflects his philosophy, invokes original intent, says present-day public opinion or consequences should not be considered, and calls the General Assembly the branch intended to wield the most authority in North Carolina.”
John S. Arrowood (Democratic)
We have not found a statement or vote from this candidate on this issue yet.
On reading state statutes: Bell says judges should faithfully apply the law as enacted by the legislature, even if they advocate changing it.
“the judge will faithfully apply the law as enacted by the legislature”
On reading state statutes: Bell says judges should give substantial weight to the words and guidance the legislature uses when drafting laws.
“I believe that words have meaning and that when the legislature drafts a law that we need to weigh heavily on the legislature's guidance”
On reading state statutes: Bell favors applying the law’s original public meaning rather than treating it as a living document.
“The conservation of law occurs when judges apply its original public meaning. As a judge, I am a textualist of the law and do not believe the law is a living, breathing document.”
On reading state statutes: Bell says judges should apply the law as written and avoid judicial activism.
“He argues that judges should apply the law as written and avoid judicial activism.”
Tobias (Toby) Hampson (Democratic)
Mixed or in between
On reading state statutes: Hampson says legal analysis should start with faithful application of the text while recognizing how decisions affect people’s lives.
“Every analysis of statutes, constitutional provisions, or common law precedent must start with a review and faithful application of the text of the relevant provisions to the facts of a case. Judges must be mindful, however, that we do not operate in a vacuum and the decisions we issue directly impact the lives of North Carolinians in all 100 counties and in communities big and small.”
On reading state statutes: Hampson says judges should apply the Constitution’s foundational principles to modern circumstances and evolving technology and society.
“the sort of the brilliance and the resilience of our Constitution is it's given us those foundational blocks that we can build from, that we can use to interpret into modern situations with evolving technology, evolving understanding of society, evolving understanding of what it means to take part in society.”
On reading state statutes: Hampson says constitutional principles should be applied to modern circumstances and evolving technology and society.
“But the sort of the brilliance and the resilience of our Constitution is it's given us those foundational blocks that we can build from, that we can use to interpret into modern situations with evolving technology, evolving understanding of society, evolving understanding of what it means to take part in society.”
On reading state statutes: Hampson says real-world consequences should not necessarily drive a decision, but a correct application of the law should make sense in the real world.
“It should not necessarily drive the decision-making process, but my judicial philosophy is very much that when we do apply the law correctly, when we interpret the law correctly, that it should make sense in the real world.”
On reading state statutes: Hampson says interpretation should start with the text and apply the law in a way that recognizes the realities of people's lives.
“Every analysis of statutes, constitutional provisions, or common law precedent must start with a review and faithful application of the text of the relevant provisions to the facts of a case. Judges must be mindful, however, that we do not operate in a vacuum and the decisions we issue directly impact the lives of North Carolinians in all 100 counties and in communities big and small. It is important we apply the law faithfully and in a way that recognizes the reality of peoples’ lives and and in a way that makes sense.”
On reading state statutes: Hampson says interpretation should start with faithful application of the text while recognizing the realities of people’s lives.
“Every analysis of statutes, constitutional provisions, or common law precedent must start with a review and faithful application of the text of the relevant provisions to the facts of a case. Judges must be mindful, however, that we do not operate in a vacuum and the decisions we issue directly impact the lives of North Carolinians in all 100 counties and in communities big and small. It is important we apply the law faithfully and in a way that recognizes the reality of peoples’ lives and and in a way that makes sense.”
On reading state statutes: Hampson says statutory interpretation begins with the statute’s language, considered alongside the facts, precedent and procedural context.
“it begins, number one, with the language of the statute”
On reading state statutes: Hampson says the law, when properly interpreted and applied, should make sense in real life.
“The law, when properly interpreted and properly applied, should absolutely make sense in real life”
On reading state statutes: Hampson says the law, properly interpreted and applied, should make sense in the real world because it affects people’s lives.
“The law, when properly interpreted and applied, should make sense in the real world because it impacts real people and real lives.”
“I think the number one issue is simply following the Constitution as written.”
On reading state statutes: Collins says judges should not consider present-day public opinion or consequences when interpreting statutes or constitutional provisions.
“When applying or interpreting the text of a statute or constitutional provision, is it ever proper for a judge to consider present day public opinion or consequences? No.”
On reading state statutes: Collins says judges should look to the authors' intent when a text is ambiguous or silent, not to their own policy preferences.
“When text is ambiguous or silent on a disputed issue, looking to the intent of the authors becomes necessary. The judge's personal policy wishes should be irrelevant.”
On reading state statutes: Collins says the Constitution should be followed as written and its meaning does not change without an amendment.
“The Constitution should be followed as written. Documents do not change meaning or wording absent following the Amendment process.”
On reading state statutes: Collins says he follows the Constitution as written and will not rewrite it to advance a political agenda.
“I believe that the Constitution means what it says and as a judge, I follow it. I will never rewrite the Constitution to advance my own political agenda.”
On reading state statutes: Collins says judges should follow the Constitution as written and not amend it through court decisions.
“I believe the Constitution means what it says. I think judges should follow it and judges should never amend that Constitution through court order.”
On reading state statutes: Collins says judges should not use court orders to amend the law.
“Collins said at the NC Faith and Freedom Coalition’s Salt and Light Conference last month that the court needs judges who won’t use the courts to “amend the law … through court order.””
Christine Marie Walczyk (Democratic)
Leans toward: its purpose and present-day circumstances
On reading state statutes: Walczyk rejects a single interpretive approach and says judges should consider words, their purpose, practical consequences and present-day situations.
“I pay attention to the words, the purpose of the words, the practical consequences of the words, and we make the best decisions we can.”
On reading state statutes: Walczyk rejects an originalist approach and says judges should apply the law to real-world situations.
“I can’t subscribe to the originalist idea where we’re tied to the framers (who) wrote a document in the 1700s when African Americans and women had no rights,” Walczyk said on PBS NC’s State Lines. “I think that judges are required to apply the law to real world situations.”
On reading state statutes: Walczyk says courts should consider evolving society and moral values when interpreting the state and federal constitutions.
“And when we look at those, we have to understand that society evolves. And moral values change. We have to look at it through that lens.”
On reading state statutes: Walczyk rejects an originalist approach and says judges must apply the law to real-world situations.
“I can’t subscribe to the originalist idea where we’re tied to the framers (who) wrote a document in the 1700s when African Americans and women had no rights,” Walczyk said on PBS NC’s State Lines. “I think that judges are required to apply the law to real world situations.”
On reading state statutes: Walczyk says North Carolina courts should interpret and enforce law in a way that reflects the state's values and priorities.
“The North Carolina Constitution provides the framework for lawmaking, elections, and local governance, and serves as the foundation for state courts to interpret and enforce the law in a manner that reflects the values and priorities of our state.”