VotingVibe

Review of criminal appeals: where the candidates stand

Michigan 2026 General Midterm Election

The court reviews claims of legal error in criminal convictions and sentences.

From “Give greater weight to finality when reviewing convictions” to “Give greater weight to scrutiny of claimed errors”.

Updated November 3, 2026 from published sources.

Judge of Court of Appeals

Michael J. Kelly (NO PARTY AFFILIATION)

We have not found a statement or vote from this candidate on this issue yet.

Allie Greenleaf Maldonado (NO PARTY AFFILIATION)

Leans toward: Give greater weight to scrutiny of claimed errors

  • Maldonado dissented from the conclusion that there was sufficient evidence of premeditation to support a first-degree murder conviction.

    “However, I do not agree with the majority’s conclusion that the prosecution presented sufficient evidence to establish premeditation.”

Michelle M. Rick (NO PARTY AFFILIATION)

Leans toward: Give greater weight to scrutiny of claimed errors

  • Rick joined an opinion vacating a life-without-parole sentence and remanding it for reevaluation under the proper framework.

    “For the reasons provided below, we vacate and remand for reevaluation under the pro per framework.”