Criminal justice: where the candidates stand
Michigan 2026 General Midterm Election
How the law treats someone accused or convicted of a crime.
From “finality: sentences stand, appeals narrow” to “scrutiny: more review, more rehabilitation”.
Updated November 3, 2026 from published sources.
Judge of Court of Appeals
Michael J. Kelly (NO PARTY AFFILIATION)
We have not found a statement or vote from this candidate on this issue yet.
Allie Greenleaf Maldonado (NO PARTY AFFILIATION)
Leans toward: scrutiny: more review, more rehabilitation
On review of criminal appeals: Maldonado dissented from the conclusion that there was sufficient evidence of premeditation to support a first-degree murder conviction.
“However, I do not agree with the majority’s conclusion that the prosecution presented sufficient evidence to establish premeditation.”
Michelle M. Rick (NO PARTY AFFILIATION)
Leans toward: scrutiny: more review, more rehabilitation
On review of criminal appeals: Rick joined an opinion vacating a life-without-parole sentence and remanding it for reevaluation under the proper framework.
“For the reasons provided below, we vacate and remand for reevaluation under the pro per framework.”